10 Comments
User's avatar
Rate Disparity's avatar

Survival constraint is a very clever and apt name for your blog and a very important financial principal in general. Mehrling is of course one of the most competent and clear speakers on the mechanics of money and banking.

The inside-outside spread visualization is an incredibly useful graphic for understanding market making. The idea that market makers can reliably profit using a markup or discount, despite market volatility, is simple enough, but I have always struggled to visualize it. Thanks for sharing that.

I also talk about "survival" in my rate disparity book, but in the context of assessing interest equilibriums, as there is a mismatch between expected returns and realized post-hoc returns:

https://ratedisparity.com/wiki2/index.php/Rate_Disparity_Book

I am still working on making that book better and simpler and clearer, as I tried to tackle a lot and took a lot of speculative and complex ideas.

Alex Howlett's avatar

I'm glad you like the Treynor diagram. Mehrling uses it throughout his Economics of Money and Banking lectures. I highly recommend them.

I'll have to take a look at your book. I'm not sure if you get into this, but something that Mehrling emphasizes in his money view is the importance of *nominal* interest rates over "real" interest rates as reflecting tightness in the money market. If what you're trying to do is roll over your cash commitments, then it's the nominal interest rate you need to be paying attention to, not the real one.

Obviously, the real interest rate matters, too. And the two are connected. However, the money view starts from the nominal side, unlike Fisher, who emphasizes real interest rates.

Rate Disparity's avatar

My book is certainly dense and wandering, but I try to hit the important points up front.

In my view, Nominal rates are not necessarily restrictive, even for money markets, because they can be mathematically equivalent to a "stock split", ie redivision of the money unit.

In this vein, I identify a third form of inflation:

1. demand pull

2. cost push

3. price drift

demand pull inflation may be indicated by increased real consumption, cost push by a consumption decrease, and price drift is completely neutral, as it would reflect this kind of "stock split" inflation.

the one apparent form of definitive "stickiness" in prices is policy levels: min wage, tax brackets, public benefit and salary levels, etc.

So my view might be the opposite of mehrling on this point! but I think it is a tricky thing to discuss clearly.

Alex Howlett's avatar

Hmm. I'm not following your stock split point.

The money view starts with time patterns of cash flows and cash commitments. That's an entirely nominal world. The money rate of interest is the price you have to pay to relax the survival constraint.

And yes. Mehrling doesn't really talk about the price level or inflation so much in the lectures. Again, that's because we're talking about an entirely nominal world.

Mehrling is recently working on integrating the price level a bit more. But I think he still has some work to do.

https://youtu.be/2pr3svEbaew?si=-IJ0dEeLlnGDSIob

Rate Disparity's avatar

the stock split analogy is essential for understanding interest relativity and interest rates as an intertemporal exchange rate.

Rate Disparity's avatar

You must be able to distinguish between a neutral rate level and an equilibrium level in order to be dimensionally neutral. Agents tend think in dimensionally neutral terms. the payment system is only a "nominal world" in as much as it operates according to a regulatory unit of account. Thus IOR is functionally a stock split.

In a stock split one money unit gets divided into multiple units. So 1 share gets redivided into 5 shares.

Interest potentially is the same, except at a very granular level: 1 share gets redivided into 1.05 shares. Or 100 shares are now 105 shares.

But this is only a "change of dimensional basis" it is not anything structural. Mathematically it is an accounting isomorphism.

I'm not saying interest is always a stock split, but you have to recognize the possibility.

Credit restrictiveness is primarily determined by collateral appraisal, which is essentially the price level, in Mehrling's "four prices of money" except collateral appraisal dictates the price level.

Again, my book is messy, but it tries to discuss this. interest as a "price of money" is entirely a circular definition.

I discussed this as a guest on the appliedMMT podcast.